Well I went to see Gods and Generals at our local mega-movie cineplex, and I have just a few comments.
First of all, casting Ben Affleck as Stonewall Jackson was quite a bold move. I thought that the maroon latex costume was a little overdone, and I don't remember reading anywhere about General Jackson being blind, but the metaphor was quite profound. Seeing him leap from building to building, singlehandedly fighting the Yankees on sheer instinct alone, not having his eyesight, was a really accurate depiction of how the Confederate Army was a scrappy lot, underdogs if you will, but were really fighting the good fight, protecting hearth and home, albeit with a few "blindspots" in their values.
Jennifer Garner as Anna Jackson was just amazing. I know that depicting her fighting like a ninja might have been a little over-the-top and anachronistic, but I thought it worked. I just loved it when Stonewall said, "My Esposita, you do a fine job with those fork-looking-oriental-sword-thingys... a fine job." and she replied, "Darling, our God is a Yankee-butt-kicking God."
I thought it might have been a bit of a stretch seeing Ving Rhames play President Lincoln, (who evidently was also known as "The Kingpin"), since most historical representations of Lincoln show him as a gaunt and gangly baboon of a white man, but I caved on this one. I think it worked.
I had to get up and go to the bathroom right near the middle, and I must have missed something important, because when I got back it was the part of the movie where Baloo was carrying Mowgli through the forest on his back, running from Shere Khan. Now I'm not an authority by any stretch, but I could have sworn that Baloo was no where near Fredricksburg. I'm quite positive that Baloo was with the 5th Tennessee, which everyone knows was holding the line in northern Mississippi under General Johnston and which never even fought in the Eastern campaign.
I have to say that taken as a whole, the movie was choppy, without rythm or pace and had very little plot. Some of the devices, while interesting, really make no sense on further reflection. Why change from live action to total animation halfway through the film? And why don't we see General Jackson again in the second half? Is he supposed to be somehow "represented" by the brave little Indian boy stoically singing about the "Bare Necessities of Life"? I just don't get it.
The worst part of the whole experience was trying to find my way out of the theater. I spent half an hour walking down corridor after corridor until I finally found an exit. While I was wandering around, though, I did catch a glimpse of a couple of other things that were showing at the time. One movie, I think it was titled "Daredevil" or something, had a bunch of people standing around in nineteenth-century period costumes talking to each other. That one looked pretty gay.